Judgment of 12 December 2018, Case No 30 Cdo 2584/2016 – Compensation for the increased living costs abroad in the context of employment contract
Employment contract, compensation for the increased living costs abroad
Judgment of the Supreme Court of 12 December 2018, Case No 30 Cdo 2584/2016
(Employment contract, compensation for the increased living costs abroad)
The case concerns a claim of a former Czech diplomat in Spain for compensation from the state. She argued that the Czech authorities and the courts did not grant her compensation for the increased living costs abroad after termination of her working contract (since then, she has not worked abroad). In the previous proceedings, the applicant was not successful neither before the first-instance nor the second-instance court. The Supreme Court subsequently stated that the institute of the compensation for increased living costs is aimed to balance the actual reduction of earnings when the respective person works in a more expensive country. Thus, if the worker does not actually work abroad, he or she cannot suffer a financial loss and there is no harm if the worker does not receive the compensation. The Constitutional Court of the Czech Republic also rejected the complaint of the applicant. Following these facts, the applicant claimed the compensation of 2,000,000 CZK from the Czech Republic. The claim of the applicant was dismissed before both the first instance and appellate courts.
The Supreme Court firstly dealt with the question of the conditions of the liability of the state in the context of the case-law of the Court of Justice of the European Union. It stated that the conditions are as follows: The aim of the breached rule is to award rights to individuals, the breach is sufficiently serious and there has to be a causal link between the breach and the damage of the individuals. The case was assessed in the context of the Article 157 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (“TFEU”). The Court stated that the wording of the provision in question and the content of the case law of the Court of Justice of the EU do not lead to the conclusion that the purpose of the respective provision was to harmonize the system of the salaries across the Member States in the case of invalid termination of working contract. Consequently, it has to be concluded than that the fact that the Supreme Court in the previous proceedings did not apply the Article 157 of the TFEU was not a manifest breach of the EU law, regardless of how would this Article be interpreted within the claim for compensation for loss of earnings resulting from the invalid termination of the employment contract. If one of the basic conditions for constituting the liability of the state for the breach of the EU law on the necessary level of seriousness was missing, the claim for the compensation based on the liability could not be constituted. Therefore, the Supreme Court of the Czech Republic dismissed the extraordinary appeal.