Judgment of 20 September 2012, Case No 20 Cdo 3939/2010 – International jurisdiction in enforcement by sale of movable assets
EU Law: discontinuation of an enforcement by sale of movable assets – international jurisdiction
Czech Republic – Supreme Court – Decision No. 20 Cdo 3939/2010 – Sept. 20, 2012
(discontinuation of an enforcement by sale of movable assets – international jurisdiction)
This case concerned an extraordinary appeal lodged by creditors against the judgment of a Regional Court, which, after the case having been determined identically by a District Court, ruled under Section 326a of Act No. 99/1963 Coll., the Rules of Civil Procedure, to discontinue enforcement by sale of movable assets. Both the courts based their determinations on the fact that the inventory of movable assets was taken to no avail since the automobile included in that inventory could not be sold in auction. The first auction did not take place as a result of the debtor’s request for temporary suspension of enforcement, and the second auction did not take place either, since no bidder appeared and, in the meantime, the automobile had been transported by the debtor to his place of residence in the Slovak Republic. All the assets of the debtor that could be included in the inventory were now located in the Slovak Republic. The appellate court ruled that the enforcement could only be carried out in the Czech Republic and the conditions for the discontinuation thereof had therefore been met.
The creditors based the admissibility of the extraordinary appeal on significant legal importance, since the matter of possibility of enforcement where the debtor has wantonly transported inventoried movable assets to another country had never been addressed.
The Supreme Court of the Czech Republic held that an extraordinary appeal that has not been preceded by a cassation judgment may be admissible only in the event of significant legal importance that may only be justified using Section 241a(2) of the Rules of Civil Procedure (erroneous determination of the law of the case).
The Supreme Court of the Czech Republic did not support the claim of the appellants that the matter lacked background in case law. In addition, the Supreme Court ruled that neither the Czech-Slovak legal assistance treaty no. 209/1993 Coll. nor the Brussels I Regulation applied to the legal relationship in question. This means that the relationship was governed by the Czech laws, specifically by the Rules of Civil Procedure. In order for the condition of significant legal importance to be met, the appellants would have therefore had to challenge erroneous interpretation or application of that law, specifically of Section 326a of the Rules of Civil Procedure. However, the appellants did not do that and the Supreme Court of the Czech Republic therefore could not attach significant legal importance to the issue in question. As a result of those conclusions, the Supreme Court of the Czech Republic rejected the extraordinary appeal as inadmissible.