Judgment of 23 January 2013, Case No 22 Cdo 2628/2010 – Review of the validity of an arbitration clause
EU Law: Review of the validity of an arbitration clause
Czech Republic – Supreme Court – Judgment No 23 Cdo 2628/2010 – January 22, 2013
(Review of the validity of an arbitration clause)
The plaintiff instituted a suit against the defendant, seeking vacation of an arbitration award in the case of an action for the payment of amounts due under a lease agreement. The obligation under that agreement passed to the plaintiff by the death of the original debtor. According to the District Court, a valid arbitration clause was agreed to by the parties to the proceedings as part of the lease agreement; the rights and obligations passed to the plaintiff, and the mere death of the lessee did not cause the termination of the lease agreement.
The fundamental question in these proceedings was whether or not the courts were obligated to examine the termination of the arbitration clause ex officio, and whether or not the arbitration clause agreed to by the parties was valid. The Supreme Court supported the appellate court’s ruling that the arbitration clause was an independent agreement and that the termination of the primary (lease) agreement did not automatically entail termination of the arbitration clause. The lease agreement between the plaintiff’s legal predecessor and the defendant was entered into in a relationship between a consumer and an entrepreneur, and it therefore was necessary to interpret the Arbitration Act consistently with Council Directive 93/13/EEC on unfair terms in consumer contracts (hereinafter referred to as the “Directive”) and with the case law of the Court of Justice of the European Union. The EU-consistent interpretation requires that the validity of the arbitration clause be reviewed in judicial proceedings ex officio even where the consumer has not sought invalidity of the arbitration clause in proceedings before arbitrators.
The Supreme Court therefore examined the nature of the arbitration clause in question. The parties to the lease agreement had agreed that any and all future disputes would be resolved by an arbitrator chosen ad hoc by the petitioner. The choice of the arbitrator therefore depends on the will of one of the parties, and it can be assumed that the petitioner will, most probably, be the defendant as a member of the Association of Leasing Companies of the Czech Republic. The arbitrator was supposed to be chosen from a list kept by that Association, which, moreover, was not of the nature of a permanent court of arbitration. The arbitration clause was therefore invalid due to violation of law under Section 39 of the Civil Code and under Section 56(1) of the Civil Code.
The lower courts did not deal with the question of validity of the arbitration clause ex officio, and the Supreme Court therefore vacated their decisions and remanded the case to the first-instance court for further proceedings.